Philip Gipson

This didn't feel Lifetime-ish to me, and I truly feel that it should've gone all out with its storyline. But the onscreen chemistry between LeToya Luckett, Jamall Johnson, and Sherilyn Allen was just too good to ignore.

It was near perfect for me. Still, with the way it ended, it deserves a sequel.

Just like the last two Secrets on Maple Street films, this one was low on plot. This final movie in the trilogy had me thinking that Alex, the husband, would be the bad guy. But he was just a red herring.

This movie went absolutely nowhere for me. There was supposed to be plenty of oomph in its plot, but there wasn't.

This sequel to last week's movie was definitely no better. It was basically characters wandering around aimlessly trying to accomplish their objectives.

This movie was pretty weird, but at least they cast actual twin siblings to play twin siblings.

What a seriously impactful movie this was. The fact that Garcelle Beauvais co-executive produced it really makes it all the more meaningful.

I just watched yet another Lifetime/LMN movie with a misleading title. If you create a catchy title such as that, then the plot should live up to it. But on the bright side, it reunited Kirsten Robek and Matreya Scarrwener from Cradle Did Fall.

I figured that the whole "secret" aspect of the movie would be further delved into. Instead, the movie was just all over the place.

This was kind of a boring movie for me to watch. I fully expected it to go all in with its storyline. I thought its four main actors were well cast, though.

I loved this movie completely. It fired on all cylinders with the plot threads that it had.

Natalie Sharp getting to play a Lifetime villainess finally was the best thing about this movie for me. She needed that chance so badly, and she got it. I hope it's not the last time either.

The movie was fine despite its faults. I was especially glad to see Corin Nemec back on Lifetime, because his presence was very much missed.

I'll be honest -- I mainly tuned in for the movie simply because of Ryan McPartlin. He really nailed the sleaziness of the Aaron character.

It was kind of a weird movie for me, but the twists and turns kept me glued.

It was close to perfect. I thought that Rebecca Dalton and Marcus Rosner had pretty good chemistry onscreen.

It wasn't quite a perfect movie, but I liked it for a certain freelance actress for Lifetime. ;)

I admit that the movie could've highlighted more of Ruth's backstory, but I believe Teri Hatcher did the very best that she could as Ruth. She should definitely play an actual villainess in a Lifetime movie one day.

Honestly, I feel like this movie could've leaned more into its love-triangle aspect. It was a letdown for me.

As silly as this movie was, Billy Zane made it pretty bearable. He embodied the real-life Larry Ray perfectly.

This movie was near perfect for me. Still, the way Gabby manipulated her way into the life of Jessica and her family tells me that we really do need a sequel.

This movie's storyline was so boilerplate. I figured that Brooke and Stefan would be super evil and that their plotting would be so much better than just a nightclub. Also, the subplot concerning the aunt was random and made zero sense.

What an incredibly twisted sequel! I enjoyed watching it all, especially the climax!

Not even Bethenny Frankel could elevate this movie to cult status. I feel like its storyline could've leaned more into the mystery and dorm aspects.

The setting was really nice. It felt like I was really in Greece. The plot, however, could've used a little more spice. I did like it for Danielle C. Ryan. I recognize her from her Lifetime movies.